• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • Bio
  • Bookshelf
    • Audio
    • Complete List of Chautona’s Books
    • The Rockland Chronicles
      • The Vintage Wren
      • The Aggie Series
      • The Hartfield Mysteries
      • Sight Unseen Series
        • Sight Unseen Series Archives
      • The Agency Files
      • Christmas Fiction
    • Legacy of the Vines
    • Meddlin’ Madeline
      • Madeline Blog Archive
    • Ballads from the Hearth
      • Ballads from the Hearth Blog Archive
    • Legends of the Vengeance
    • Journey of Dreams
    • Wynnewood
    • Webster’s Bakery
    • The Not-So-Fairy Tales
    • Heart of Warwickshire
  • Start HERE
    • If You Like…
    • Characters
    • Suggested Reading Order
    • Free Books
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Podcast
    • Advertising
    • Podcast Guest Information
    • Podcast Interview FAQ
  • Merch Shop
  • Nav Social Menu

    • Email
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter
    • YouTube
  • Bonus
  • Speaking
  • New & Coming
Chautona Havig

Chautona Havig

Using story to connect YOU to the Master Storyteller

Why Amish Fiction Is Crazy Popular & More

by Chautona Havig · 3 Comments

Amish fiction has its champions and its critics, but when it comes to Christmas stories, who can resist? Check out Amish Christmas Miracles! via @chautonahavig

Amish fiction tends to be a bit polarizing. Readers tend to love it or hate it. Are the criticisms valid?  One has to wonder because, despite the naysayers, Amish fiction has a huge following. What is so appealing about Amish fiction, what do readers expect, and is the claim that “If you’ve read one, you’ve read them all” a fair one?

Amish author, Jennifer Beckstrand, joined me in a conversation about Amish fiction, her books, and a super exciting collection that released today, Amish Christmas Miracles.

Why Amish Fiction Is Crazy Popular & More

Note: links may be affiliate links that provide me with a small commission at no extra expense to you.

Why Amish Fiction Is Crazy Popular & More

I had a list of questions that probably took poor Jennifer for a wild ride, but anyone who visits many of the Christian fiction Facebook groups, the Goodreads discussions, or just chats Christian fiction with friends knows that Amish fiction has rabid fans and derisive critics.  Knowing how readers felt about that, I thought it would be nice to get an author’s perspective.  I asked about:

Why people like Amish fiction.

Jennifer loves it because enjoys a happy story, and she said that people appreciate the simplicity of the lifestyle and that it’s a kinder, gentler romance than many contemporary romances.  I’m going to out her here and share that while I cut it out of the audio, she did coin a new word. “Kindler.”  We had a good laugh over that.

She also made a fascinating point about how it really does combine historical fiction with contemporary. That really hit home with me because the first Amish fiction I really loved was Suzanne Woods Fisher’s Anna’s Crossing series.

Additionally, one of Amish fiction’s most criticized elements is also why it is popular. Jennifer shared that publishers like it because Walmart does.  Readers know exactly what to expect from a book with an Amish cover.  The very predictability of general Amish plots is also what those readers like.  I found that fascinating.

They also love the strong faith element of people whose entire lives are an act of worship.

Are all Amish stories really the same?

Not hardly. For example, in the collection we discussed, there are fourteen different Amish authors and Jennifer reckons that this probably means fourteen different locations including Maine and Maryland–two states that I didn’t know had Amish communities.

Some say that the characters in these books are a bit too “perfect,” and Jennifer admits sometimes they are.  She and many authors like her, however, enjoy writing more flawed, relatable characters.

I pointed out that the tendency to write “Mary Sue” characters is by no means limited to Amish fiction, and after some reflection, I think that like many others, I’ve often held Amish fiction to a higher standard than other fiction. That doesn’t seem quite right, does it?

So we ended up discussing how genre fiction all have formulas within each genre and how the author’s job is to avoid turning it into a cliche.

All the Amish aren’t all alike!

Not just location differences, but cultural differences within those locations make all Amish stories different.  They actually put a foreword in Amish Christmas Miracles pointing out that the different places would have different lives, rules, traditions, and things.

Jennifer also talked about her original research when she decided to write Amish fiction, and after immersing herself in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania Amish culture, she decided to set her books in Wisconsin and was dismayed to learn from an Amish friend that those Wisconsin folks were very different!

People have ideas about what Amish is and isn’t and when we impose our ideas of what is and isn’t sufficiently Amish, we’re kind of arrogant.  Fun fact: In my daughter’s Amish town, I saw an Amish man getting out of a car at McDonald’s, talking on the phone.  That’s okay there. However, they’re only allowed to use a certain kind of (uncovered in crazy cold Indiana, no less) sort of buggy.  Larger families have “three-buggy garages” because they need them to fit everyone into said buggy!

When I read Buried Secrets by Rachel J. Good, my knowledge of the Amish was limited to groups NOT like the one Rachel was writing about and that yes, some Amish do decorate nurseries for their babies!

Why is Pennsylvania Dutch used where it is and when it is?

People love varying amounts of the Pennsylvania Dutch in their books, and as we were talking about it, I realized it would be a good thing to have a list of authors who use a lot and others who don’t use as much for folks who enjoy it.

Jennifer likes to use just enough to create that setting–a reminder to the reader that these people are actually speaking and thinking in Pennsylvania Dutch.

Amish Christmas MiraclesThe Amish Christmas Miracles Collection

Jennifer (J.E.B.) Spredemann was talking about how she wanted to do a box set, so eventually, those two and Rachel J. Good got together and found eleven more authors who wanted to do it.

Now I read Jennifer’s story, Peanut Butter Christmas, and seriously.  Amish, Santa Claus, Miracles, and faith struggles… what more could you want from a Christmas story. How about absolutely adorable twin boys who don’t quite get how this Santa thing works.  I also told my own Santa story from my childhood.  Eeep!

The authors are as follows and I’m listing a few of each authors’ books that I thought you might want to take note of:

Jennifer Beckstrand

  • The Matchmakers of Huckleberry Hill series
  • Sweet as Honey from the Honeybee Sisters series
  • Andrew from the Petersheim Brothers series

Kathleen Fuller

  • Amish Christmas Miracles
  • Amish Christmas Wedding
  • A Double Dose of Love

J.E.B. Spredemann

  • The author’s Amazon page

Dana R. Lynn

  • Her Amazon page of various series

Susan Lantz Simpson

  • Plain Discovery  (Book One of the Plainly Maryland Series)
  • The Promise (Book One of the Amish of Southern Maryland Series)
  • Rosanna’s Gift  
  • Lizzie’s Heart   

Ashley Emma

  • Amish Alias
  • Undercover Amish

Lenora Worth

  • Their Amish Reunion
  • Her Amish Child
  • Seeking Refuge
  • Amish Christmas Hideaway

Serena B. Miller

  • Her Amazon page of various titles

Loree Lough

  • A Little Child Shall Lead Them Series
  • Mistletoe and Murder: A Christmas Suspense Collection

Rachel J. Good

  • His Unexpected Amish Twins
  • His Pretend Amish Bride
  • His Accidental Amish Family 
  • Amish Christmas Twins

Laura Bradford

  • The author’s Amazon page

Tracy Fredrychowski

  • Secrets of Willow Springs – Book 1
  • Secrets of Willow Springs – Book 2
  • The Amish Women of Lawrence County
  • Love Blooms at the Apple Blossom Inn

Adina Senft

  • The Wounded Heart
  • Herb of Grace

Mary Alford

  • Amish Country Murder 
  • Amish Country Kidnapping

The collection is .99 but only until 11/15/2020, so grab it now!

The regular retail price is 9.99, so you really want to grab it fast.  Seriously, Jennifer’s story is worth the dollar price tag several times over all by itself, so grab it while you can.

Share384
Pin
Tweet
Email
384Shares
Share
Pin
Tweet
Email
384Shares

Related

Filed Under: Because Fiction Podcast Tagged With: podcast

Previous Post: « What Do Pretty Ribbons Have to Do with Ugly Murder?
Next Post: What Does Christian Romance Offer That Readers Need? »

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Or, you can subscribe without commenting.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments

  1. Alicia Haney says

    November 10, 2020 at 1:25 pm

    Thank you for sharing about this awesome sounding book. I love Amish stories and I love Christmas. Have a Great week and stay safe.

    Reply
  2. Jennifer Beckstrand says

    November 10, 2020 at 8:10 am

    Chautona, what a delightful blog! Thank you so much for interviewing me on your podcast. I had so much fun. We definitely need to do it again sometime. Hugs and blessings!

    Reply
  3. Karen Morgan says

    November 10, 2020 at 7:44 am

    Have you read any Amish books by author Linda Byler? She has vivd descriptions and unusual settings and plots.Her bio indicates that she is still a member of an Amish church, and I feel like her books are truly authentic Amish. Als you mentioned “Amish” lifestyle and tradtion varies greatly in different areas. I have only read a few of her books, SADIE’S MONTANA trilogy and several of the Christmas ones. More on TBR list. 🙂

    Reply

Primary Sidebar

The Because Fiction Podcast

The Because Fiction Podcast
The Because Fiction Podcast

Taking the pulse of Christian fiction

Episode 283: A Chat with Debut Author Denise L. Barela
byChautona Havig

Having the chance to chat with a dear friend about her book is always a treat.  So when Denise L. Barela chatted to me about her mystery, Silencing the Siren, I knew we’d have a lot of fun. Boy, did we. From the first ideas on this mystery through the new series she’s considering, and where she wants to take her writing in the future, Denise has a lot to share.  Listen in to learn about her writing and how you can listen to her book free!

note: links may be affiliate links that provide me with a small commission at no extra expense to you.

Why an Almost Love At First Sight Mystery Actually Works!

Denise L. Barela’s debut novel is the seventh in the Ever After Mysteries. These fairy-tale retellings set in the twenties (and now the forties!) feature fun mashups of those beloved tales with some kind of mystery. Denise chose “The Little Mermaid” and went to town combining 1920s New York City and Coney Island with that fairy tale and a freak show attraction that causes all kinds of trouble in various ways.

One thing I liked is how the “love at first sight” aspect of the original story played out in Denise’s. She focused on Annabel’s character and, being so different from the superficiality he lived with, it drew him in.  No, it’s not a romance, but this mystery does have romance in it, and Denise made that tough trope work.

The research Denise did involved widely differing topics–from novelty gifts (doorbells, folks!), to car technology advancements, to just how hard it was to find a map of New York City for the era!

Of course, that sparked a discussion on research for her other book and how she discovered rewritten history ruining her plans for it.  Enter rewrites. Sigh.

Finally, we discussed the sorts of books she wants to write, her conversation with Jaime Jo Wright, and where she plans to take things after she does one more mystery-themed series.  Clue is coming like you’ve never seen it.

Silencing the Siren by Denise L. Barela

Andrew Grayson thought he had everything… until he met her.

The indulged son of wealthy parents, Andrew has always gotten whatever he wanted almost before he knew he wanted it—clothes, gadgets… even a car! What more could a young man desire?

Enter Annabel Thompson. Freakshow mermaid extraordinaire… in a wheelchair!

Of course, her beauty attracts him. How could it not? Add to that a kind heart, and Andrew can’t help but fall for her.

Annabel’s connection with the freakshow repels his parents and their society friends. They want him to sever all ties with her and his new friends. Oh, and marry the “right” girl with the “right connections.” But he won’t do it. He’ll defy them and marry his little mermaid.

When Annabel turns up missing, declared dead, things don’t add up, Andrew begins asking some difficult questions, the most important being, “What happened to the little mermaid of the Coney Island freak show?”

Find out in this next book in the Ever After Mysteries, combining beloved fairy tales and mysteries. Silencing the Siren offers a retelling of “The Little Mermaid” that will keep you gripped to the edge of your seat as you watch the story unfold.

Learn more about Denise L. Barela on her WEBSITE and follow her on GoodReads and BookBub.  You can listen to Silencing the Siren free on her YouTube Channel.

Like to listen on the go? You can find Because Fiction Podcast at:

  • Apple 
  • Castbox 
  • Google Play
  • Libsyn 
  • RSS
  • Spotify
  • Amazon
  • and more!
Episode 283: A Chat with Debut Author Denise L. Barela
Episode 283: A Chat with Debut Author Denise L. Barela
November 28, 2023
Chautona Havig
Because Fiction: A Chat with Split-Time Author, Melanie Dobson
November 25, 2023
Chautona Havig
Episode 281: A Chat with Angela Hunt
November 23, 2023
Chautona Havig
Episode 280: A Chat with Debut Author, Johanna Rojas Vann
November 21, 2023
Chautona Havig
Because Fiction 279: A Chat with Amish Author, Leslie Gould
November 17, 2023
Chautona Havig
Episode 278: A Chat with WWII Author, Amanda Barratt
November 14, 2023
Chautona Havig
Episode 277: A Chat with M. D. House about Sophia
November 11, 2023
Chautona Havig
Episode 276: A Chat with Jaime Jo Wright about Her New Release
November 7, 2023
Chautona Havig
Episode 275: A Chat about Knowing You by Tracie Peterson
November 3, 2023
Chautona Havig
Because Fiction 274: A Chat with Sara Beth Williams about No Matter How Far
October 31, 2023
Chautona Havig
Search Results placeholder

Love Audio Books?

audio book ad

Check out the Sparrow Island novels. A tiny island with a lot of heart

independence islands series

Featured Books

A Ransomed Grete

A Ransomed Grete
Buy This Book Online
Buy from Amazon
Buy from Amazon Kindle
A Ransomed Grete
Buy now!

Twice Sold Tales

Twice Sold Tales
Buy This Book Online
Buy from Amazon
Buy from Amazon Kindle
Twice Sold Tales
Buy now!

Under the Hibiscus

Under the Hibiscus
Buy This Book Online
Buy from Amazon
Buy from Amazon Kindle
Under the Hibiscus
Buy now!

Upcoming Posts

  • Why This Author Sold Me on a Whole Series in One Fun Interview (October 28, 2023)

Or just subscribe to the newsletter

Recent Blog Posts

  • Why an Almost Love At First Sight Mystery Actually Works!
  • How a Family Mystery Sparked the Idea for a Beautiful Story
  • How Angela Hunt Keeps Delivering Great Books to Her Fans

I buy my stickers here! (affiliate)

Custom Stickers, Die Cut Stickers, Bumper Stickers - Sticker Mule
I should be editing the podcast or writing, but i I should be editing the podcast or writing,  but it's been a long day,  and I haven't read all week. So, quick reading break with some Hungarian coffee cake and a cup of tea. Oh, and On Moonberry Lake by @hollyvarni 
#AmReading 
#LyonsGold
Or just love a suspenseful novel? Reposted from @ Or just love a suspenseful novel?

Reposted from @lisaphillipsbks Now that the weather has turned chilly, are you pining for the summer sun? ☀️🌴 Well, you're in luck because it's not too late to get your copy of Come What May, volume 3 of our Summer Heat series, and escape to summer in collection of FOUR novels! Head over to my link in bio to find your copy before it's gone.

 #weekendreading #weekendreads #summerheat #SummerReading2023 #summerreading #summerheatseries #avidreadersofchristianfiction #deals #bookseries #weekendread #bookshelf #2023reads #tbr #readmorebooks #bookstack #faithwriter #ChristianFiction #authorlisaphillips #ebooks #readerlove #christianromanticsuspense #romanticsuspenseseries #comewhatmay
Oh... how I need to learn this lesson! Sigh. Comin Oh... how I need to learn this lesson! Sigh.
Coming December 6! Preorder coming VERY soon! EEEP!
#Bookstrings
#ClockTowerBound
#BerneIndiana
#BookishBooks
#ChristFic
#AmWriting
How did I manage to wait this long to start this? How did I manage to wait this long to start this? I'm ready to move to Moonberry Lake.
@hollyvarni 
#AmReading 
#ChristFic
Tonight's reads. What's on your TBR tonight? #AmR Tonight's reads.  What's on your TBR tonight?
#AmReading 
@nadinebrandes 
#ChristFic 
#Eschatology
Day 4: Vacation Read I LOVE collections for vacati Day 4: Vacation Read
I LOVE collections for vacation reads. They're usually a bit shorter (these aren't novellas but they are shorter novels) and there are usually several options to choose from. 
I love the Summer Heat Series, and not just because I've got a book in there!
#BookishChallenge
Day 3: Colorful Colors Well, I made myself choose Day 3: Colorful Colors
Well, I made myself choose books that are in the shed-i-ffice instead of going and looking at what I had throughout the house. These were some that were bright and vivid. I've only read parts of two of them (plan to finish The Major and the Missionary tomorrow and Fawkes I'll start reading on the 5th for obvious reasons). #BookishChallenge
  • Home
  • Bookshelf
  • New & Coming
  • Blog
  • News!
  • Disclosure & Policies
  • Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2023 · Chautona Havig · All Rights Reserved · Coding by Gretchen Louise

Don't go before you grab your FREE short story collection!